You did say it in your earlier post but maybe you didn't realize that you said it. If the minimum wage is tied to a fixed formula based on the cost of living AND employes raise their prices to pay for the new higher wages then that raises the cost of living, doesn't it? Ergo, wages must go up again to maintain the living wage and it's an escalating cycle. Eventually the higher prices will eliminate the need for the job unless it stabilizes before that.
This makes the assumption that the entire economy hinges on the lowest paid workers and that a change in the minimum wage makes a huge... in Trump speak,
YUUUGE difference. This is just not the case. While it is true that the cost is passed on to the consumer and raises the price, the amount of money is negligible in the overall economy. There is no need to fear a "critical mass" and runaway inflation. If you're worried about inflation, pray we never get any significant tax cuts for the middle class!
A Happy Meal is gross and I don't care whether it's cheaper or not. If we get rid of guest workers, we will have to fill in with American workers. We have close to a million foreign workers in the US, doing jobs that Americans could do. We are paying people not to work while we bring someone in from another country to do a job. It would be a more moral use of government to encourage and train people in real job skills and not replace them with cheap overseas labor. The government should operate to benefit the citizens of the country, not to screw them over.
So, it's simple and elegant plan. Get rid of the foreigners (including the high paid white collar ones too I assume), get rid of any kind of government assistance, get rid of the minimum wage, let the market find out how low we can go and then the lazy poorly educated Americans will rise to the occasion and become productive with little incentive other than they
may not starve to death. Oh yeah, and hit 'em with a flat tax too!
There's just one yuuuuge problem with that plan. There is a middle ground between marginal employment and starving to death. That is crime.
If you push the marginal people to these extremes, they will turn to crime for sure. The worst that can happen to them then is they go to jail and get taken care of. If they think they can be good at crime they think they can work their way up and let's face it, everybody thinks they are smarter than the average bear but a very, very few actually are. Let's see... pay whatever we do now, or put these people up at the Holiday Inn for the rest of their lives... hmmm.
Now you might say, "Well, we'll make prison so horrible that they would never pick that option!!" Never minding international standards for prison standards, let's say that is implemented and prison becomes like it was in say the 18th century. This is the point at which you now have an insurrection and an uprising. This is where people like ISIS move in like a cancer. This is why most countries pay their worthless people to settle the hell down.
How do
I say we fix it???
- Admit that we will always have poor people in this country. In fact capitalism demands it.
- Admit that it is worth the money to take care of these people on the front end rather than prison.
- Work to reduce the numbers of poor by breaking the cycle of poverty and by real rehabilitation.
- Pay young women living below the poverty line to not have children. Basically cash for no kids.
- Those women living below the poverty line that do have kids, you give quality free day care and primary education of their kids.
- Set up real education and work programs programs for those that apply themselves, that have guaranteed jobs after graduation for people in prison.
- Advocate and support trade schools, apprenticeship programs and specialized skill boot camps rather than just college after high school.
If we do these things we will shrink the poor population and the cost to support the poor population gets lower and lower. More and more people will have a better basic education and even a work ethic that can set them on paths to living above the minimum wage rather than just becoming career minimum wage earners.
The problem we have now is we have a whole class of people that are either totally unemployable, or are so learning impaired that pushing a broom is all they can do in life. Numerous studies have shown that this learning impairment that creates this cycle of poverty begins before a child even goes to the first grade. Basically learning impaired people are teaching the next generation of learning impaired people how to be useless.
Break this cycle and we have less poor people, less expense to support poor people and less need for a minimum wage. To put all this in the context of this thread, we basically need a minimum wage because we are now stuck with a whole group of marginal workers who's entire career is going to be at, or near the minimum wage because they are learning impaired and by the time they are adults, it is very difficult to change that.